Report this Argument Con Thank you for your quick response. I'm just going to cut to the chase here over the relevant points of the debate. The one contention that is actually going to matter here at the end is whether or not marriages need special legal rights. My opponent brings up hospital visits as an example.
Justices to consider family law and military benefits Posted Mon, March 13th, The former spouses, John and Sandra Howell, divorced in As part of the divorce, John — who served in the U.
InJohn opted to waive part of his retirement pay in favor of disability benefits — a common choice when it is available because, unlike retirement pay, disability benefits are not taxable.
After the Arizona courts agreed with her, John asked the U.
John points to Mansell v. Sandra and the federal government, which filed a brief supporting her, respond that timing is the key difference between this case and Mansell. The retirement pay in Mansell, Sandra emphasizes, had already been waived at the time of the divorce.
It only barred states from treating retirement pay that has been waived in favor of disability pay as something that can be divided when a couple divorces.
The court did not address what happens to retirement pay that has been waived in favor of disability pay when, as here, the waiver happens after the divorce.
John counters that the history or lack thereof of the provision barring courts from dividing up retirement pay actually weighs in his favor.
Amy Howe, Argument preview:Funding for this project was provided by the United States Department of Health Services, Administration for Children and Families, Grant FE Any opinions, finding, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Department of Health.
Divorce Hits Home When life was so much shorter, there was barely time to live out one s adult life with a single mate.
Today, the thought of twenty, thirty, or even forty years in a bad relationship can be a very weighty factor in deciding to leave (Ahrons 43). Many people in the United St.
Mar 13, · In this case, the United States stresses, Sandra and John’s divorce decree did not divide up any retirement pay that had been waived in favor of disability pay.
Three Logical Arguments for Divorce Settlement By Ronald S. GRanbeRG The syllogism states Wanda’s position: Major Premise All ambiguous prenup terms are unenforceable.
applying logic’s inductive generalization argument to a . Explore the pros and cons of the debate Gay marriage should be legal in the United States. DEBATES. OPINIONS.
|6 Arguments All Couples Have Before They Divorce | HuffPost||Legal questions, practical concerns at play in post-divorce life insurance case Posted Mon, March 19th, 5:|
|Talk:Grounds for divorce (United States) - Wikipedia||The Complete Guide to Divorce Law. How to File Your Own Divorce.|
|FastStats - Marriage and Divorce||Sometimes, however, leaving a marriage is best for the health, happiness, and safety of everyone involved.|
FORUMS. POLLS. Google Search. Gay marriage should be legal in the United States. I've never switched my argument in favor of non-government recognized marriages.
Mar 19, · Symposium before the oral argument in United States v.
Microsoft; Symposium before the oral argument in Minnesota Voters Alliance v. but concerns about the practical effect of their ruling could sway them toward a decision in favor of Mark’s children.
telling Ginsburg that those states also have revocation-on-divorce .